Chart

The best-novel lists skipped the 1970s

Novels first published in the 1970s hold 74 places on the 15 all-time lists. The 1960s hold 133 and the 1980s 130. The dip shows up in ten of the 15 lists taken one at a time, and not one 1970s novel reaches the All-Time Canon.

The 1970s novels the lists do pick are a mixed bunch. The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy and A Bend in the River are on the most. If you like finding books the lists have half forgotten, it's a good decade to explore.

The best-novel lists skipped the 1970sA column per decade of first publication, its height the number of places those novels hold on 15 all-time lists, stacked by tier. The 1970s have 74 places, against 133 for the 1960s and 130 for the 1980s.All-Time CanonEssentialAcclaimedRising StarOn 2+ lists, no tierOn one list only50100150Before 1800: 43 list places from 14 books; All-Time Canon 20; Essential 12; Acclaimed 5; On one list only 6Before18001800s: 0 list places from 0 books1800s1810s: 33 list places from 8 books; All-Time Canon 24; Essential 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 31810s1820s: 2 list places from 2 books; On one list only 21820s1830s: 7 list places from 4 books; Essential 3; Acclaimed 2; On one list only 21830s1840s: 41 list places from 12 books; All-Time Canon 29; Essential 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 61840s1850s: 28 list places from 11 books; All-Time Canon 12; Essential 4; Acclaimed 5; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 51850s1860s: 40 list places from 11 books; All-Time Canon 30; Acclaimed 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 21860s1870s: 28 list places from 10 books; All-Time Canon 18; Acclaimed 3; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 51870s1880s: 17 list places from 8 books; All-Time Canon 5; Acclaimed 5; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 31880s1890s: 35 list places from 14 books; All-Time Canon 12; Essential 9; On 2+ lists, no tier 8; On one list only 61890s1900s: 42 list places from 21 books; Essential 4; Acclaimed 17; On 2+ lists, no tier 12; On one list only 91900s1910s: 43 list places from 22 books; All-Time Canon 6; Essential 5; Acclaimed 15; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 131910s1920s: 109 list places from 45 books; All-Time Canon 40; Essential 23; Acclaimed 7; On 2+ lists, no tier 14; On one list only 251920s1930s: 107 list places from 47 books; All-Time Canon 16; Essential 29; Acclaimed 16; On 2+ lists, no tier 23; On one list only 231930s1940s: 81 list places from 37 books; All-Time Canon 19; Essential 15; Acclaimed 19; On 2+ lists, no tier 6; On one list only 221940s1950s: 152 list places from 72 books; All-Time Canon 51; Essential 17; Acclaimed 32; On 2+ lists, no tier 13; On one list only 391950s1960s: 133 list places from 61 books; All-Time Canon 35; Essential 23; Acclaimed 23; On 2+ lists, no tier 16; On one list only 361960s1331970s: 74 list places from 43 books; Essential 6; Acclaimed 36; On 2+ lists, no tier 13; On one list only 191970s741980s: 130 list places from 71 books; All-Time Canon 25; Essential 14; Acclaimed 30; On 2+ lists, no tier 27; On one list only 341980s1301990s: 102 list places from 67 books; Essential 14; Acclaimed 19; On 2+ lists, no tier 30; On one list only 391990s2000s: 93 list places from 57 books; All-Time Canon 29; Essential 14; Acclaimed 14; On 2+ lists, no tier 17; On one list only 192000s2010s: 32 list places from 31 books; All-Time Canon 1; Essential 3; Rising Star 7; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 172010s2020s: 6 list places from 6 books; Rising Star 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 1; On one list only 12020sThe 1970s gap: 74places, against 133 forthe 1960s and 130 forthe 1980s
The best-novel lists skipped the 1970sA column per decade of first publication, its height the number of places those novels hold on 15 all-time lists, stacked by tier. The 1970s have 74 places, against 133 for the 1960s and 130 for the 1980s.All-Time CanonEssentialAcclaimedRising StarOn 2+ lists, no tierOn one list onlyBefore 1800: 43 list places from 14 books; All-Time Canon 20; Essential 12; Acclaimed 5; On one list only 6< 1800431800s: 0 list places from 0 books1800s01810s: 33 list places from 8 books; All-Time Canon 24; Essential 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 31810s331820s: 2 list places from 2 books; On one list only 21820s21830s: 7 list places from 4 books; Essential 3; Acclaimed 2; On one list only 21830s71840s: 41 list places from 12 books; All-Time Canon 29; Essential 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 61840s411850s: 28 list places from 11 books; All-Time Canon 12; Essential 4; Acclaimed 5; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 51850s281860s: 40 list places from 11 books; All-Time Canon 30; Acclaimed 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 21860s401870s: 28 list places from 10 books; All-Time Canon 18; Acclaimed 3; On 2+ lists, no tier 2; On one list only 51870s281880s: 17 list places from 8 books; All-Time Canon 5; Acclaimed 5; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 31880s171890s: 35 list places from 14 books; All-Time Canon 12; Essential 9; On 2+ lists, no tier 8; On one list only 61890s351900s: 42 list places from 21 books; Essential 4; Acclaimed 17; On 2+ lists, no tier 12; On one list only 91900s421910s: 43 list places from 22 books; All-Time Canon 6; Essential 5; Acclaimed 15; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 131910s431920s: 109 list places from 45 books; All-Time Canon 40; Essential 23; Acclaimed 7; On 2+ lists, no tier 14; On one list only 251920s1091930s: 107 list places from 47 books; All-Time Canon 16; Essential 29; Acclaimed 16; On 2+ lists, no tier 23; On one list only 231930s1071940s: 81 list places from 37 books; All-Time Canon 19; Essential 15; Acclaimed 19; On 2+ lists, no tier 6; On one list only 221940s811950s: 152 list places from 72 books; All-Time Canon 51; Essential 17; Acclaimed 32; On 2+ lists, no tier 13; On one list only 391950s1521960s: 133 list places from 61 books; All-Time Canon 35; Essential 23; Acclaimed 23; On 2+ lists, no tier 16; On one list only 361960s1331970s: 74 list places from 43 books; Essential 6; Acclaimed 36; On 2+ lists, no tier 13; On one list only 191970s74the 1970s gap1980s: 130 list places from 71 books; All-Time Canon 25; Essential 14; Acclaimed 30; On 2+ lists, no tier 27; On one list only 341980s1301990s: 102 list places from 67 books; Essential 14; Acclaimed 19; On 2+ lists, no tier 30; On one list only 391990s1022000s: 93 list places from 57 books; All-Time Canon 29; Essential 14; Acclaimed 14; On 2+ lists, no tier 17; On one list only 192000s932010s: 32 list places from 31 books; All-Time Canon 1; Essential 3; Rising Star 7; On 2+ lists, no tier 4; On one list only 172010s322020s: 6 list places from 6 books; Rising Star 4; On 2+ lists, no tier 1; On one list only 12020s6
Source: The Novel Index, from 15 all-time lists: Guardian 2026, Guardian (McCrum) 2015, Observer 2003, BBC Culture 2015, BBC Arts 2019, Telegraph 2009, Time 2005, Modern Library 1998, Bokklubben World Library 2002, Le Monde 1999, Big Read 2003, Guardian readers 2026, Big Jubilee Read 2022, Great American Read 2018, Amazon UK 2014.Download image (PNG)
The numbers behind the chart
DecadePlacesBooksAll-Time CanonEssentialAcclaimedRising StarOn 2+ lists, no tierOn one list only
Before 1800431420125006
1800s00000000
1810s3382440023
1820s22000002
1830s74032002
1840s41122940026
1850s28111245025
1860s40113004042
1870s28101803025
1880s178505043
1890s35141290086
1900s422104170129
1910s432265150413
1920s109454023701425
1930s1074716291602323
1940s81371915190622
1950s1527251173201339
1960s1336135232301636
1970s7443063601319
1980s1307125143002734
1990s102670141903039
2000s935729141401719
2010s32311307417
2020s66000411

How we made this

One place is one book on one list. We used the 15 lists of the best novels across many decades: critics' lists, readers' polls and a bookseller's list. The two lists of 21st-century books are left out, since they would pile up the newest decades. Each book sits in the decade it was first published.

Seven of the lists were made before 2010, too early for most books from the 2000s on, which is part of why the columns fall away after the 1980s. The colours show each book's tier on The Novel Index, so a column's height is how often the lists chose that decade, and its colours show how strongly they agree on its books.

How The Novel Index works

Lists used in this chart